I don't think you can really say yes or no because Humans are the only conscious being we know of, and as such we are the only beings able to apply logic, and our mind to problems... There is no other species in which we can compare our intelligence because all other lifeforms known to us operate on instinct. Is it stupid that we are destroying the planet? You could argue that because humans are conscious and intelligent they therefore supercede natural selection, but in being such they experience things differently, therefore us destroying the planet is us carrying out natural selection on ourselves... Meanwhile you have the guy saying "Well God isn't stupid, so we can't be."... And I stand by my arguement of 'it is impossible for something so unnaturally cruel to exist.'