*And the Petro perimeter defense pop-up and waste them all*

 

Well the least they can do is add some associated cost with them going bye-bye for a bit. I dunno what would be reasonable though.

Dumb, very dumb. I mean look at the best selling RTS today, Rome: Total War and guess what all your heroes can die, and die easily. Heck they can die from old age even... We must have hero deaths permament!

 

Who is with me!!!

 

*A legion of stormtroopers bursts into cheers as they charge toward Petroglyph's offices!

 

Hazah!

*An army of one comes rushing to Petro's offices*

Be reasonable. If we want to convince them to do otherwise (if Petroglyph is truly open to persuasion at this point), let's be serious. Stormtroopers aside.

 

I might get up in arms about useless crap like "is ____ moddable?", and I might have sobbed for a day or two like the rest of everyone when I heard the SSD wasn't in, but this is the only EaW news tidbit that I find completely unacceptable.

 

Our best bet would be some form of petition, or something. I think they're cool dudes like that...if we cause enough intelligent noise, that is.

 

What say you all to that?

IMHO, I say they already made up their minds and you'll have about much sucess with this as you would trying to get the SSD in. But by all means, please prove me wrong.

Ordinarily, I would agree, Swiftdraw. But Petroglyph is more of a fan's company, or at least I still believe that they are.

 

I want to know what more of everyone thinks, first. I'm considering testing the waters with a poll, to see how many potential signers there -might- be. *shrugs*

I signed the Petition of One and sent it to them! Maybe that will help! I think the Petition of the Two Thousand would work better, but see what happened to it in the movie--look in the deleted scenes of ep.III

 

P.S. I didn't really sign a petition, but i will message Delphi!

I dunno...one private message seems sort of audacious. Like "do it for your buddy, pleeeeeease?"

 

A petition is more respectful because it assumes that these are people who know what they are doing, and is takes into account that THIS IS THEIR GAME that THEY HAVE LIBERTY OVER - hense the need for a large body of people to attempt to sway them.

I dont think Delphi actually said that they CAN'T die, I think he refered that it will be very dificult to kill them(As in the movies), so dont get him wrong, I dont think Petro could do such mistake

No, they can be killed. That's not the point of contention.

 

What it seemed that he implied was that if they die, they can be respawned/resurrected, which is the lame part.

Ohhhhhh........Well thats anothers story...

I'm in agreement that they should be able to die, maybe not as easily as other stuff but they should still be able to die. If not I hope we can at least mod it so heroes can stay down for good.

That's sad news... unressurectable heros would have enhanced both realism and required skill... as well as giving us some fun options (remove all your forces from Planet X or I will blow up Planet Y which happens to have Luke Skywalker on it with my DS). Sad.

I mean look at the best selling RTS today, Rome: Total War and guess what all your heroes can die

 

By no means do I consider RTW to be one of the greats. I was bored to tears in the first 10 minutes. Also, calvary could not run over infantry like LOTR: BFME. I threw my hands up and quit after that. I'm just saying...

 

For those of you who enjoyed it, hats off.

 

We found it to be more fun to allow heroes to return in EAW, of course there is always a price.

unressurectable heros would have enhanced both realism and required skill...

 

Maybe, maybe not.

I hope we can at least mod it so heroes can stay down for good.

 

 

Have at it!

Thank you!

Well then a price? Well then thats good since it would be pure ownage if they just kept respawning and used as a hero army Juggernaut have fun making them dead

I mean look at the best selling RTS today, Rome: Total War and guess what all your heroes can die

 

By no means do I consider RTW to be one of the greats. I was bored to tears in the first 10 minutes. Also, calvary could not run over infantry like LOTR: BFME. I threw my hands up and quit after that. I'm just saying...

 

For those of you who enjoyed it, hats off.

 

We found it to be more fun to allow heroes to return in EAW, of course there is always a price.

Finally someone who shares my view of RTW cavalry against games like BFME. Anyway I guess since I like BFME that if this game is similar in how heroes are done (resurrectable) I will enjoy it too.

Finally someone who shares my view of RTW cavalry against games like BFME.

 

 

If you are going to have calvary in a RTS, they better be as good if not better than the Rohirrim from BFME. Calvary that cannot plow through infantry is just lame.

I'm not saying RTW is realistic (Because it is far from realistic, at least until I modded the c*** out of it), I'm saying that right now its nabbed more share of the market in games with one installment then anything else, including all of the C&C games. It's got fans who have never touched any other strategy game. If you guys can create a game that has that much broad spectrum appeal then have at it.

 

Personally I think the best RTS game I've ever played is actually Close Combat III: The Russian Front.

I'm saying that right now its nabbed more share of the market in games with one installment then anything else, including all of the C&C games.

 

Actually no, DOW and AOE3 currently are running the gambit. RTW is more of a niche game appealing to the more hard core strategist. You'll never see it hit C&C, AOE or Craft numbers which are well over 15 million each.

 

Hey I'm not slammin it, I just want to know why my calvary couldn't run over guys.

Up against pikemen they shouldn't have been able to... Up a against swordsmen however...

 

What was really bad was just how overpowering the Elephants were in the game.

 

S*** we're hijacking this thread, back on to dead heroes.

 

Here's a question, in EAW will Luke just be like in ANH where he only uses a blaster?

In EAW will Luke just be like in ANH where he only uses a blaster?

 

 

Good question, but there is only so much I can answer before Lucas force chokes me.

Darth Vader: "Don't make me remind you of the price of disobedience Delphi-PG."

 

Delphi-PG: "I must apolog..." *Choke*

 

Darth Vader: "Apology accepted Mister Delphi.

Hmm I say he does just, because it wouldn't be a star wars game without Luke using a lightsaber. Plus it would be the balance for lightsaber users.

 

Luke, Obiwan, Yoda vs Emperor, Vader, Mara Jade.