I don't know how their ranking system works for games that haven't been released yet, but I often find their reviews to be pretty good once the games do come out. They go into dept about both the pros and cons of a game. I think the ranking system for games that haven't been released yet, is more of what game is most anticipated and they may setup their ranks by the number of clicks a game gets. EAW was ahead since a demo was released and that caused a lot of pple to click on EAW while BFMEII demo was just released yesterday causing a lot of clicks there. Just a guess.