Thoughts on Revenge of the Sith -- Long

[Mad78]

Jar Jar... Worst character ever made I think.

after TPM Anakin

I kind of agree with you Kaja. Even if Jar Jar didn't serve any perticular role (he does though in the AotC) in TPM I found him supportable and his goofing about could make you smile... BUT ANAKIN!!! ***bashes head against table*** i just can't get over him!

[kaja]

Even my Little brother (7) Hates TPM Anakin, that's somthing we can all agree on.

[Warstomp]

My thought was the hole begining part with the battle over corosant is that they rushed it kinda fast it seemed like it was wiping through and alesoden we where with the media people. Also i thought that they sould of gotten a better person to play anikan he just didont seem to evil enough. Also i think for the hole killing the jedi part they sould of showed some of that. I was thinking the reason mace window was owning palpatine but yoda wasent was look at this palpatine was fighting far and square saber fights first at yodas fight he fought far and yoda was beating him they he went and started just flinging those senate chairs at him witch i consider cheating he didont even fight he just flung chairs at him. And i cant think of what else i was going to say.

[Mad78]

Cheating is the way of the Sith

[Skynxnex]

I hate to say it but the definition of a 'fair fight' is somewhat elusive. Technically speaking anyone who is going to fight someone else, be it an army or a one on one, the people involved engage in something called 'maneuvering' where the participants of said fight try to get what is called the 'high ground' or in other words the best position available. Positioning in a fight can mean everything. Also, what is available? Some people believe that using your environment in a fight is ok, others dont. Really the definition of fair is hard to define. Is it fair for smaller armies to fight larger armies and win? What about training and discipline etc.?

[Mad78]

Well a fair fight is often considered as one where an opponenet didn't cheat... But again, in a battle what is cheating and what isn't?

[Skynxnex]

Well a fair fight is often considered as one where an opponenet didn't cheat... But again, in a battle what is cheating and what isn't?

 

Exactly.

 

Like I said, what exactly is 'fair' in a fight.

[Mad78]

I guess that if a fight becomes fair it will become a sport. Look at boxing. Rules are set out and there is nothing (well most of the time) personnal involved.

Other fights normally appear because somebody is unfair to another. How could the fight be fair in that case?

[kaja]

Who cares of it's a fair fight, as long as you win

[Mad78]

Good point.

[Q]

I saw Jar Jar for a split second. Thats 5 minuts too many.

[kaja]

If it's only for a split seccond, why even care?

[Darth_Rob]

I swear I heard him mumble "hello" or some such nonsense to Palpatine when he returned from his "imprisonment".

[Evaders99]

Basically all he says is 'Excuse me' when he bumps into another Senator on the platform

[Eko]

I'm not too bothered if Jar Jar makes a tiny cameo, its just extended dialogue, particularly between him and the Child-anakin that irritates me personally.